Thirty-seven years ago, Bishop Michael Begley led 26 bishops from across 13 states in issuing a landmark pastoral letter on the state of the poor in Appalachia: "This Land is Home to Me."
It had been only three years since he was ordained and installed as bishop of the new Diocese of Charlotte, and "This Land is Home to Me" attracted national attention for its forthright approach to the problems of people in the economically depressed region that included western North Carolina. The cause was one near and dear to his heart: Bishop Begley's involvement with the mountain region had begun during his tenure as director of Catholic Charities for the Diocese of Raleigh and continued throughout his episcopacy.
"This Land is Home to Me" was promulgated on Feb. 1, 1975, at what is now Wheeling Jesuit University.
THE PASTORAL LETTER'S SIGNIFICANCE
In issuing this pastoral letter, Bishop Begley and the other bishops were acting in partnership with the Catholic Committee of Appalachia, a lay organization formed in 1970, to shine the spotlight on the economic disparities and political powerlessness of the people of Appalachia as well as the major commercial exploitation and destruction of the area's resources. Forty years later, the CCA still stands in solidarity with the people of the Appalachian region, and focuses on issues of concern to them such as mountaintop removal mining, labor rights, private prison development, sustainability and climate change, clean air and water, health care and racism.
According to the CCA, the pastoral letter is "widely recognized as (one of) the most influential indigenous writings of the Catholic Church in our times."
The West Virginia Encyclopedia calls the pastoral letter "one of the most significant statements to emerge from the U.S. Catholic Church and has become a model for groups all over the world that are interested in writing on matters of social justice. More than 200,000 copies of the pastoral (letter) are in circulation, and it has been translated into several languages."
The pastoral letter was also groundbreaking in two respects: it was developed with lay involvement – particularly people about whom it was written and directed – and it was written in a free-verse poetic style.
The West Virginia Encyclopedia also describes that "'This Land is Home to Me' was written in response to the concerns raised by the Catholic Committee of Appalachia in 1974 regarding the economic and political inequalities that characterized the Appalachian region. Over the course of the following year, members of the committee traveled throughout Appalachia, listening to individuals, community groups and church workers. The stories that came out of these visits were then incorporated into the writing of the pastoral letter, which was grounded in Scripture and the teachings of the Catholic Church on social justice."
Its collaborative, inclusive approach was a major influence on subsequent pastoral letters coming from the U.S. bishops over the next generation.
EXCERPTS FROM THE PASTORAL LETTER
"This Land is Home to Me" begins with this opening call:
Many of our Catholic people especially church workers have asked us to respond to the cries of powerlessness from the region called Appalachia. We have listened to these cries and now we lend our own voice. The cries come now from Appalachia, but they are echoed across the land, across the earth, in the suffering of too many people. Together these many sufferings form a single cry.
The Living God hears this cry and tells us, what long ago on a different mountain, was told the servant Moses that, God had heard the cry of a people. God would deliver them out of the hands of oppression. God would give them a rich and broad land.
There is a saying in the region that coal is king. That's not exactly right. The kings are those who control big coal, and the profit and power that come with it. Many of these kings don't live in the region. ...
The way of life that these corporate giants create is called by some "technological rationalization." Its forces contain the promise of a world where
– poverty is eliminated,
– health is cared for,
– education is available for all,
– dignity is guaranteed,
– and old age is secure.
Too often, however, its forces become perverted, hostile to the dignity of the earth and of its people.
Its destructive growth patterns
– pollute the air,
– foul the water,
– rape the land.
The driving force behind this perversion is "maximization of profit," a principle which too often converts itself into an idolatrous power. ...
Great fortunes were built on the exploitation of Appalachian workers and Appalachian resources; yet the land was left without revenues to care for its social needs, like
– old age,
– and illness. ...
Worse still, swallowing us up in things is the power of the idol which eats away at our openness to the Living God. ...
Once we all
– knew how to dance and sing,
– sat in mystery before the poet's spell,
– felt our hearts rise to nature's cathedral. ...
Now an alien culture battles to shape us into plastic forms empty of Spirit, into beasts of burden without mystery.
It references past U.S. bishops' letters as well as papal encyclicals emphasizing economic balance and social justice, including Pope Leo XIII's 1891 letter "Rerum Novarum" ("On the Condition of the Working Classes") and the writings of Vatican II.
It advocates for "action centers" to be set up throughout Appalachia to welcome the poor, share resources, build grass-roots efforts, and gather together in prayer.
And the pastoral letter concludes:
For it is the weak things of this world which seem like folly, that the Spirit takes up and makes its own. The dream of the mountains' struggle, the dream of simplicity and of justice ... is, we believe, the voice of Yahweh among us.
In taking them up, hopefully the Church might once again be known as
– a center of the Spirit,
– a place where poetry dares to speak,
– where the song reigns unchallenged,
– where art flourishes,
– where nature is welcome,
– where little people and little needs come first,
– where justice speaks loudly,
– where in a wilderness of idolatrous destruction the great voice of God still cries out for Life.
ITS CONTINUING INFLUENCE
"This Land is Home to Me" remains a North Star that guides bishops in the Appalachian region today.
In 2010, Bishop Michael J. Bransfield of Wheeling-Charleston referenced "This Land is Home to Me" in a pastoral letter he promulgated regarding coal mine safety. "On My Holy Mountain" called attention to mine safety in the wake of mine disasters including the April 5, 2010, explosion at Upper Big Branch Mine that killed 29 miners.
In addition to its historical significance in form, style and substance, "This Land is Home to Me" spurred a follow-up pastoral letter in 1995 entitled "'At Home in the Web of Life: A Pastoral Message on Sustainable Communities in Appalachia" by the Appalachian bishops and the CCA. In it, the bishops advocated the creation and defense of sustainable communities in Appalachia through responsible stewardship of the land and its resources – the most important being its people.
Closer to home, the 1975 letter had a tangible impact.
In 1997, then Bishop William G. Curlin and then Raleigh Bishop F. Joseph Gossman published the pastoral letter "Of One Heart and One Mind," highlighting disparities in economic opportunities in the state. That spurred the Charlotte diocese to commission a study of the needs and assets of its far western region, and, in response to those results, the diocese founded the Office of Economic Opportunity (OEO) within Catholic Social Services in 1999.
One year later, in 2000, Bishop Curlin opened the Bishop Begley Center for Economic Development in Murphy – the main base of operations for OEO, which spans the Appalachian counties of Cherokee, Clay, Graham and Swain. For the past nine years, OEO has hosted a biennial conference to continue the dialogue about how to improve the lives of the people in Appalachia. Aptly named the Bishop Begley Conference on Appalachia, this year's fifth conference will focus on "supporting rural economic growth in far western North Carolina through sustainable agriculture," and will be held Friday, March 23, in Cherokee.
OEO also funds "Growing Opportunities Grants" to support local non-profit organizations and community groups in these four far western rural counties of North Carolina. Over the past 11 years, OEO has awarded more than $220,000 to empower people, create jobs and support community development.
On the 35th anniversary of the historic pastoral letter, the newspaper of the Diocese of Wheeling, W.Va., "The Catholic Spirit" reported that it "still has a profound effect..."
Monsignor Frederick P. Annie, vicar general of the diocese, stated, "It has helped many of the people who live in Appalachia to grow in their appreciation and their pride in who they are as a people and what their history is, and for them to acknowledge the richness of their tradition and their struggle."
— Patricia L. Guilfoyle, editor
EDITOR'S NOTE: The Diocese of Charlotte was founded on Jan. 12, 1972. To celebrate the 40th anniversary of the diocese and the history of the Church in western North Carolina, we are publishing a year-long series spotlighting the people who built up the Church, the major developments over the past 40 years, and what changes could be in store for the future.
The 1975 pastoral letter "This Land is Home to Me" is online at: www.catholicconferencewv.org/pdf/ThisLandIsHome.pdf.
Learn more about the Office of Economic Opportunity at www.cssnc.org/oeo.
Deacon James Toner: What we know that ain't so: In vitro"What you think is the right road may lead to death" (Prv 14:12) What we think is the right road About one in five couples in the United States experiences infertility. This is often a cause of great suffering among those couples, for many...
Dr. Kamila Valenta: Middle East policy must include protecting ChristiansOver the past several months we have seen reports of the horrific crimes of the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria – ISIS (also known as ISIL – the Islamic State of Iraq and Levant). This extremist rebel group that now controls large parts...
Sister Constance Veit: Whose life is it anyway?In college I wrote a medical ethics paper on a play entitled "Whose Life Is It Anyway"? That old paper came to mind recently when I learned that the campaign for physician assisted suicide has been gaining momentum. The renewed push to legalize...
Deacon James Toner: What we know that ain't so: Gud EdjakashunWhat we think is the right road About five years ago, Mark Bauerlein challenged readers by contending that we must learn not to trust anyone under the age of 30. What he called "the dumbest generation" has achieved "viewer literacy," Bauerlein...
Father Tadeusz Pacholczyk: 'Redefining' marriage?In the current debate over gay "marriage," people sometimes ask: Who should define marriage? Democrats or Republicans in Congress? The Supreme Court? Should it be put to a referendum, allowing the majority to choose a definition? We can identify...
Robert D. Potter Jr.: What's wrong with homosexual marriage?The U.S. Supreme Court is set to consider whether a state is required to recognize homosexual "marriage" under the 14th Amendment to the Constitution. In the flood of secular media messages and accounts, many Catholics may be confused and even...
Anne Tinsdale: Offer it up"Offer it up": the great mantra of our beloved Catholic school nuns! What did they know that we can learn about sacrifice and suffering? On a purely human level the value and necessity of sacrifice and suffering is difficult to imagine, but...
LETTERS FROM OUR READERS
Synod survey questions didn't need to be so difficultThe Feb. 13 edition of the Catholic News Herald published an article regarding the process of information gathering by the Synod of Bishops on the Family, specifically the difficulty of the survey...
Abortion reversal kits give women a second chanceIt is a scary, cruel world nowadays. That anxiety can be multiplied tenfold when you are a pro-life emergency department health care provider, like me. The emergency department is filled with...
Tired rhetoric of race only creates division, not unityIn response to the Jan. 16 commentary "Race, bias and fear of 'the other,'" we were both compelled to write a response. Read original commentary here. As...
MOST POPULAR STORIES
FROM THE PASTORS
Read and listen to homilies posted regularly by pastors at parishes within the Diocese of Charlotte:
- Fr. Roger Arnsparger at St. John the Baptist in Tryon
- Fr. Frank Cancro at Queen of the Apostles
- Fr. Jason Christian at St. Thomas Aquinas in Charlotte
- Fr. Patrick Earl at St. Peter in Charlotte
- Fr. Matthew Kauth at St. Thomas Aquinas in Charlotte
- Fr. Timothy Reid at St. Ann in Charlotte
- Fr. Christopher Riehl's archive from St. Thomas Aquinas in Charlotte
- Fr. Benjamin Roberts at Our Lady of Lourdes in Monroe. Listen to homily podcasts.
- Fr. Joshua Voitus at St. Mary, Mother of God Parish in Sylva, including homilies in Spanish
- Fr. Patrick Winslow at St. Thomas Aquinas in Charlotte
- Gospel reflection videos from St. Matthew Church
- Watch full Masses live and on demand, listen to homilies and reflections from Sacred Heart Church in Salisbury
- Listen and watch homilies from St. Thomas Aquinas in Charlotte
- Listen to homilies from St. William Catholic Church in Murphy